NEW STARTUPS

Startups that you can invest in with as little as $100 right now:

☀️ Dermasport - The skincare trusted by olympians (LINK)

☕️ Manna Coffee - Redefining the coffee kiosk (LINK)

🥤 Jovē - Water that enhances cellular hydration (LINK)

Phantom Stock: The Startup Equity That Isn’t Quite Equity

In startup land, not everything is what it seems.

There’s common stock. There’s preferred stock. There are SAFEs, convertible notes, option pools, and founder shares.

And then, there’s phantom stock.

It sounds like something out of a Wolf of Wall Street - but for investors eyeing community rounds, phantom stock is very real. And if you're not asking about it, you might be missing something important about how your investment actually fits into the cap table.

Let’s break down what phantom stock is, why startups use it, and what you should be asking before investing in a company that’s issued it.

What Is Phantom Stock?

Phantom stock is a type of employee compensation that gives the recipient the economic benefits of owning equity - without actually granting them equity.

It’s essentially a promise: if the company gets acquired or goes public, the holder of phantom stock will receive a cash payout equivalent to what their shares would’ve been worth.

In some cases, phantom stockholders receive dividends as if they were shareholders, though they don’t actually have voting rights or a place on the cap table.

In short: phantom stock walks like equity, talks like equity, but isn’t technically equity.

For startups, it’s a way to reward employees or advisors without diluting ownership or navigating the messy logistics of issuing real shares. For the recipient, it can be lucrative—but it's a bet on a future liquidity event, and there’s no guarantee it’ll pay off.

A Brief History of Phantom Stock (and Why It’s Trending Now)

Phantom stock isn’t new. It first emerged in the 1980s as large private companies—often family-run businesses—looked for ways to retain executives without giving up ownership.

But in the past few years, it’s made its way into the startup world. As cap tables grow increasingly complex and competition for talent heats up, phantom stock offers a cleaner, faster way to offer upside.

A few tailwinds behind the rise:

• Equity complexity: Traditional stock option plans require 409A valuations, board approval, legal paperwork, and ongoing compliance. Phantom stock skips much of that.

• Crowdfunding surge: With more community investors joining the table, companies want to keep real equity tightly controlled.

• Talent wars: Early-stage startups can’t always compete on salary. Phantom stock lets them offer potential upside without legal overhead.

More founders are embracing it. More employees are asking for it. And more investors should be paying attention to it.

Why Do Startups Use Phantom Stock?

Here’s why a startup might choose phantom stock over traditional equity:

1. Avoiding Dilution

Phantom stock doesn’t reduce the ownership percentages of founders or existing shareholders. It’s a cash-based promise, not an ownership stake.

2. Simplified Administration

Startups don’t need to formally amend their cap table or issue shares. That keeps things cleaner—especially in the early stages before a formal board or HR infrastructure is in place.

3. Flexibility for Non-US Employees

Issuing equity across borders can get legally complicated. Phantom stock can be easier to manage from a compliance standpoint.

4. Protecting Control

With phantom stock, founders don’t risk ceding board votes or control to early employees or advisors. That can be appealing for mission-driven or solo founders wary of over-extending equity early on.

What Investors Need to Know About Phantom Stock

Here’s where things get real for retail investors.

Phantom stock isn’t inherently bad—but if a startup you’re eyeing has issued it, you need to understand how it could affect your investment.

First and foremost, phantom stock impacts returns. Imagine a startup sells for $100 million. If it’s on the hook to pay $10 million to phantom shareholders, only $90 million is left to distribute among actual equity holders.

Your slice of the pie might not be diluted in the traditional sense, but the size of the pie just got smaller.

It’s also important to remember that phantom stock is not equity—it’s a liability. It represents a future cash obligation the company must fulfill before distributing proceeds to shareholders. In that way, it behaves more like debt than equity, and it gets prioritized accordingly in an exit.

And here’s the tricky part: you might not even see it coming. Phantom stock doesn’t always show up on the cap table provided in crowdfunding campaign materials, since it’s not classified as equity. But just because it’s invisible doesn’t mean it’s insignificant.

Lastly, not all phantom stock is created equal. The terms vary. Some plans include performance milestones, vesting schedules, or caps on payouts. Others are more open-ended.

As an investor, it’s essential to dig into the structure and understand exactly what’s been promised—and to whom.

The Phantom Stock Investor Checklist

If you're considering investing in a startup that has issued—or plans to issue—phantom stock, here's what you should be asking:

Has the company issued phantom stock?

It might not appear on the cap table, so direct questions are your best bet. You need visibility to understand potential downstream dilution (even if it's not equity dilution).

How much phantom stock has been promised (as a % of the company)?

Knowing the scale of phantom commitments helps you model likely payouts in an exit scenario. A small pool may be negligible. A large one could materially reduce returns.

Who holds the phantom stock?

If it’s mostly early employees or advisors, that’s expected. If a large portion is held by consultants or recent hires, it might signal poor planning or lack of cash discipline.

Are there vesting schedules or performance triggers?

Some phantom stock vests over time. Others are immediate. The risk to investors increases if phantom stock payouts are automatic regardless of contribution.

What is the payout mechanism?

Is it only paid out on an exit? Are dividends included? Is it capped or uncapped? These details matter for modeling future distributions.

Has the company modeled phantom payouts in its financial projections?

If the financial plan doesn’t account for phantom obligations, future cash flow could be more strained than projections suggest.

Final Thoughts: Phantom Doesn’t Mean Fiction

Phantom stock can be a savvy move for startups. It allows lean teams to reward talent without surrendering ownership or drowning in legal work.

But as a retail investor, you need to treat it with the same scrutiny you’d give to debt, equity, or options. It’s a real financial obligation that can impact your returns—especially if it’s sizable, opaque, or mismanaged.

If you're investing through platforms like Wefunder, StartEngine, or Republic, don’t assume what you see on the cap table is the full story. Phantom stock might not be visible, but it still impacts the math.

Let me know how you felt about this article!